The Great Position Debate: Goalkeeper
Edwin Van der Sar
The best since Schmeichel but a wobble at the end of last season in his form and the up and coming Foster means that 1st choice isn’t guaranteed for the Dutchman. Maybe it was the effects of Robbie Keane’s knee that put him off slightly, and a rest will bring back his calm cool to the pitch. I sense one great season left in him.
Tomasz Kuszczak
The Polish understudy to Van der Sar has signed permanently now, which is odd considering the great season Foster has just had. Of the few starts he had, he looked competent at best, but nothing special. Which is just what you want from a reserve. Gave away a penalty against Arsenal but subsequently saved it.
Ben Foster
Young Englishman Foster came to prominence last season with a great season at Watford. Perhaps the Watford defence made him look good by keeping him busy, it is the opposite at United where he will have nothing to do for 80 minutes and then Rio will fall asleep and poke a backpass towards your net. Will he be able to step up to both United’s and England’s first team?
The Verdict
Hasn’t been much better in terms of keepers at United. My vote goes to Edwin for this season and Foster to emerge next.
All Posts in the The Great Position Debate Series
- Leftback
- Goalkeeper
Popularity: 9% [?]
July 4th, 2007 at 2:10 pm
I am in total agreement. Foster looks promising but . . .
I don’t suppose Peter’s son is old enough yet.